Emails obtained by a left-leaning watchdog show Trump attorney Cleta Mitchell pressing the Justice Department to fast-track pardons for 2020 electors facing state charges — the latest window into how allies of the president worked to unwind a justice system that jailed Americans for walking through the Capitol while violent rioters from the summer of 2020 walked free.
The exchange, obtained by American Oversight through a Freedom of Information Act request and reported by The Guardian, reveals Mitchell telling pardon attorney Ed Martin in fall 2025 that speed was critical. Criminal cases against the alternate electors were pending in Georgia, Michigan, Arizona, Nevada, and Wisconsin. "Time is of the essence," Mitchell wrote. "If trials are allowed to occur, the additional financial and emotional costs to these loyal Trump supporters will be enormous."
Martin's reply was brief: "Thank you for this. Very helpful."
Mitchell also argued that a prompt federal pardon could trigger dismissal of the Georgia case — then pending before a prosecutors' council after Fani Willis was disqualified — by removing the co-defendant charges. The prosecutor who eventually took over the case did dismiss the charges, though The Guardian notes that was for reasons unrelated to the pardons Trump issued.
Trump ultimately issued a blanket pardon for the fake electors. The Guardian framed this as "largely symbolic" since federal pardons don't touch state charges, and cast the entire effort as election deniers using "access to get President Trump to act." American Oversight's executive director, Chioma Chukwu, called it placing people "above the law." What The Guardian buried: the two-tiered justice context. While grandmothers who strolled through the Capitol rotunda on January 6 faced federal prison time, BLM arsonists who torched federal buildings and Antifa rioters who assaulted officers received deferred prosecutions and dropped charges across multiple jurisdictions. The pardon push wasn't occurring in a vacuum — it was a response to a system that punished one side of political dissent and coddled the other.
Meanwhile, the administration's picks continue to reject the institutional framing of that day. NBC News reports that Michael LoSapio, Trump's nominee to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, told Senator Richard Blumenthal at a confirmation hearing that January 6 was "not an attack." Pressed repeatedly, LoSapio — currently chief information security officer at Palantir — held firm: "I know what I saw on the news."
LoSapio also refused to say who won the 2020 election, calling it a question about "an election six years ago." Blumenthal accused him of ducking and betraying a "lack of independence." Another nominee, federal appeals court pick Cody Hiland, likewise refused to answer Blumenthal on the same question, citing ethical concerns. Blumenthal insisted the White House told nominees not to answer — a claim neither NBC nor Blumenthal substantiated with evidence.
CISA hasn't had a Senate-confirmed director since Trump returned to office. The clock is ticking: Democrats take Congress in January. Trump's first CISA director, Chris Krebs, was fired after stating the 2020 race was secure.
The institutional press calls the pardon effort a scandal. The question ordinary Americans might ask is simpler: why did a system that crushed January 6 defendants with maximum charges and pretrial detention never bring the same force against the rioters who burned American cities the summer before?








