Socialist Mayor Zohran Mamdani wants to shutter Rikers Island by 2032 — and his administration has been quietly pressuring prosecutors to release accused criminals from custody to make the math work, while working-class neighborhoods are left to absorb whatever comes next.
The plan, unveiled Friday, would push the city's legally mandated closure deadline from August 2027 to the end of 2032 and pour another $146 million into "mental health care, substance use treatment, educational and vocational programming," according to the Guardian. It comes after the city has already burned through an eye-watering $16 billion on the closure effort — with not a single replacement facility built, the New York Post reported.
The numbers don't work. The four borough-based replacement facilities are expected to hold roughly 4,500 beds combined, while about 6,600 people remain jailed on Rikers as of early November, according to the Guardian. The earliest any new facility opens is 2029 — Brooklyn first, with the Bronx and Queens following in 2031 and Manhattan in 2032.
To close the gap, Mamdani's Office of Criminal Justice has been meeting quietly with district attorneys since at least the summer, asking whether bail decisions could be revisited to thin the jail population, the Post reported. City Hall floated releasing inmates held on bail and asked a DA's office to build a "case study" of potential early-release candidates. Prosecutors scoffed at the suggestion. After examining cases individually, they found few suspects could be sprung — and the process would be difficult given the nature of the offenses, which the Post described as including violent crimes.
None of that friction appears in the Guardian's or NPR's coverage. The Guardian framed the announcement as a comprehensive plan to deliver a "safe and humane" correctional system, quoting Mamdani's statement that the city has a "legal and moral obligation to close Rikers." NPR led with Rikers' well-documented failures — more than 50 deaths in city custody since 2022, a federal judge calling the violence an "unconstitutional danger," and the city stripped of operational authority last year. Both outlets quoted Mamdani's moral framing without mentioning his administration's back-channel efforts to push accused offenders out the door.
NPR gave significant airtime to Insha Rahman, president of the Vera Institute of Justice, a criminal justice reform nonprofit that has advocated for reducing incarceration nationwide. Rahman called the plan a model for other cities to follow. NPR did not detail who funds the Vera Institute or what stake reform nonprofits have in the outcome.
The Post, by contrast, reported that Mamdani is fighting his own flank. Two Democratic Socialists of America allies on the council — Sandy Nurse and Tiffany Caban — "raged" during a briefing about extending the deadline, sources said. City Council Speaker Julie Menin said she is "committed to extending that deadline," acknowledging the city cannot meet the current one.
Mamdani appointed a "Close Rikers Czar" and tapped Stanley Richards — the first formerly incarcerated person to lead the Department of Correction — as commissioner, NPR reported. A federal remediation manager now controls Rikers operations independently after a judge stripped the city's authority last year.
The pattern is familiar. Progressive politicians mandate jail closures on moral grounds, miss every deadline, burn billions, and then look for ways to release accused offenders to make the population fit the infrastructure they failed to build. The Guardian and NPR reported the press release. The Post reported what was happening behind closed doors.
The question neither the mayor nor his allies in the reform nonprofit world have answered: when those 2,500 people are no longer held on Rikers, where exactly do they go — and who lives next door?








