The Justice Department walked away Thursday from its lawsuit seeking to block certification of Mary Peltola's victory in Alaska's U.S. Senate race — but the retreat leaves a bigger question hanging: when did federal courts become a tool for contesting state elections the president doesn't like?
The DOJ sued Alaska election officials on October 22 at President Trump's direct order. "I'm the one that said 'do it,'" Trump told reporters during his midterm blitz. The lawsuit demanded that certification be blocked until investigators could determine whether voters who chose Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. — a retired Petersburg schoolteacher who shared the incumbent Republican senator's name on the ballot — had actually meant to vote for Senator Dan Sullivan. The administration never explained how such an inquiry could work without breaching the secret ballot.
U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on November 1, two days before the election, ruling the federal government lacked standing and that setting ballots aside would violate the secret ballot. The DOJ appealed the same day.
Then Peltola won 50.13% of the vote, according to The Guardian — an outright majority that made the lawsuit's central premise irrelevant. The case was built for a photo finish: Sullivan losing by fewer votes than his namesake received. Alaska delivered a blowout instead.
In Thursday's filing, Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward wrote that the government "therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means" of examining whether votes cast for Dan J. Sullivan were intended for the senator. The DOJ also asked the 9th Circuit to vacate Gleason's ruling on the way out — a move to erase the legal loss rather than let it stand as precedent.
Alaska's Republican-controlled state government opposed the lawsuit throughout, with state attorneys calling it "meritless." The Alaska Supreme Court had already ruled in June that the second Sullivan's candidacy was legal. CBS News and the New York Post framed the lawsuit as Trump's gambit "to prevent one of his political rivals from taking office" — but the state's own Republican officials wanted no part of it, filing papers to help get the case dismissed.
The civil case is collapsing. The criminal investigation is not.
Attorney General Todd Blanche has confirmed the probe remains open. Federal prosecutors sent target letters on Election Day to several people, including Marc Elias, whose firm represents Peltola's campaign. Elias said the department was "targeting me and my law firm on Election Day." No one has been charged.
The New York Times reported texts and documents showing Peltola's campaign was involved in recruiting the second Sullivan to enter the race. Peltola denied any involvement, saying she was "not interested in tricking voters." Trump called it "voter fraud at the highest level" and demanded Peltola be prosecuted. Whether recruiting a namesake candidate breaks any criminal law remains unclear — ballot stacking is not illegal at the federal level, and the DOJ has not specified which offenses it is examining.
This is at least the second time since Election Day that the DOJ has moved to drop a high-profile election lawsuit. The first targeted roughly 20,000 California ballots the department said were cast by suspected noncitizens. California officials argued the DOJ's list was outdated and included legitimate voters. NBC News noted that in both cases, the federal government inserted itself into state-run election processes — which are conducted by state officials under U.S. law.
The pattern is plain. Both suits were filed before votes were counted. Both were dropped after the results came in. The Alaska case folded because the margin was too wide. The California case folded after Democrats flipped Congress. In neither case did the DOJ explain how it would investigate voter intent without gutting the secret ballot — the foundational protection of American elections.
The criminal probe into the "Decoy Dan" scheme may yet produce charges, or it may quietly disappear like the civil suit. Either way, the precedent is set: the Justice Department now treats election results as something it can litigate away — and only retreats when the numbers leave it no other move.








