Democrat Mary Peltola defeated incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan in Alaska, handing Democrats a 56-44 Senate majority in a race where Democratic operatives ran a decoy candidate with the same name to siphon votes — and where the result took two weeks to finalize under the state's sprawling open election system.

The stakes are straightforward: one state's experimental voting rules just helped flip the balance of the U.S. Senate. And other states are lining up to copy the playbook.

Peltola won with 50.1% of the vote to Sullivan's 45.8%, a margin of roughly 13,000 votes, with over 95% of ballots counted as of Tuesday morning, according to the Associated Press. The race was the last Senate contest decided in the 2026 midterms.

Here's where the machinery matters. A second candidate also named Dan Sullivan — Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a former schoolteacher — appeared on the ballot and received 4,760 votes. The New York Times reported in October that Democratic operatives coordinated the effort to recruit him specifically to confuse voters. The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee reportedly connected a veteran operative named Jerid Kurtz with former Peltola campaign staff. Peltola herself visited the other Sullivan's hometown days before he filed his candidacy, according to the Anchorage Daily News. Democratic strategist Amber Lee authored the press release announcing his run, metadata reviewed by the Daily Caller News Foundation showed.

Alaska's open primary system made the scheme possible: candidates can claim any party affiliation without party vetting. The other Sullivan switched from Republican to independent just eight days before the general election, the Alaska Beacon reported.

Election officials tried to block it. Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher informed the other Sullivan in an August 26 letter that his candidacy "was not filed in order to declare an actual good-faith candidacy" but to confuse voters. A Superior Court judge ruled he could stay on the primary ballot. The Alaska Supreme Court overturned that ruling on June 30 and allowed him on the general election ballot. The DSCC and Peltola's campaign celebrated the decision, the Times reported.

The Daily Caller noted the obvious: Peltola's 13,000-vote margin exceeded the 4,760 votes the other Sullivan pulled. The decoy didn't decide the race on the numbers. The Post Millennial, by contrast, led with the scheme as central to the outcome.

But the numbers don't tell the whole story. Another Republican, Gerald Heikes, received 6,105 votes. In a ranked-choice system, second and third choices get redistributed — and the presence of a spoiler candidate reshapes how voters rank their preferences from the start.

The Department of Justice issued at least three dozen subpoenas investigating the alleged scheme and filed a lawsuit to block the results if Sullivan lost. Obama-appointed U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason blocked the suit, ruling the DOJ failed to explain its authority and how the alleged fraud could be remedied.

Peltola declared victory in a video statement: "Thank you, Alaska. We did it." She pledged to "put an end to the era of self-serving politicians lining their own pockets" and to "fight corruption and corporate greed."

Donald Trump carried Alaska in 2024 by 13 points. Sullivan won his 2020 race by 12.7 points. Democrats flipped nine Senate seats this cycle, including Alaska, Texas, Kansas, and Iowa.

The open question: Alaska's system — open primaries, ranked-choice general elections, weeks of ballot processing — has now produced two straight Democratic wins in a red state. How many more states will adopt it before someone asks whether the machinery is working for voters or for the people who build it?