A 25-year-old homeless man with five pending cases walked out of a Manhattan courtroom Thursday on supervised release — despite prosecutors asking a judge to hold him on bail. By Friday, 62-year-old Jin Yu was strangled to death in her own Chinatown apartment.
This is what criminal justice reform looks like when it meets reality.
Alexander Florentino had been hauled into Manhattan Criminal Court on petty larceny and stolen property charges — just the latest in a string of six pending cases. He had already skipped court dates and had warrants issued for his arrest. The Manhattan DA's office asked Judge Juliet Howard to hold him on $3,000 cash bail or a $9,000 bond. Howard ordered supervised release instead.
The next day, police say Florentino broke into Yu's Catherine Street apartment, strangled her with a black cord, subjected her to sexual contact, and left her face-down in her own blood. He also smashed her roommate over the head with a bottle.
At his arraignment Sunday — where the New York Post reports he smiled — Manhattan Assistant District Attorney Jonathan Carfagno described the crime in grim detail. "He callously strangled her to death with a black cord, seemingly subjected her to unwanted sexual contact, and then left her dying face-down in her own blood without pants," Carfagno told the judge. Florentino was finally held without bail. For Jin Yu, that came a day too late.
New York City Councilman Phil Wong, a Democrat who sits on the public safety committee, didn't mince words. "This criminal should have been detained. He never should have been released," Wong said. "There is a problem with the criminal justice system, which is a revolving door. They get released before the paperwork is complete." Wong added that cashless bail needs to be revisited and tightened: "We're going to have criminals committing the same crimes if we let them loose."
The Chinatown killing is not an isolated failure. In Panama City Beach, Florida, an illegal immigrant from Venezuela walked free after backing his SUV over 82-year-old Deborah Murphy in a Publix parking lot, crushing her with both sets of tires. Carlos Suarez-Contreras, 26, was driving on a canceled Georgia license when he struck Murphy on May 17. He was initially charged with driving with a canceled license causing death — a third-degree felony — and held without bond because of his immigration status and flight risk.
But State Attorney Larry Basford dismissed the case after nearly six months. "I think everyone would agree that what he did was careless and it was negligent," Basford told Fox News Digital. "But not every tragedy amounts to a crime."
That is cold comfort to Murphy's daughters, Amy Edge and Beth Schulz, who watched surveillance video of their mother being struck in a crosswalk and crushed beneath both axles of an SUV driven by someone who had no legal right to be in the country, let alone behind the wheel. Prosecutors confirmed Suarez-Contreras' license had been canceled — but only a day before the accident, complicating the criminal case under Florida law.
Two cases, two states, two women dead — one 62, one 82. In New York, a judge overrode prosecutors to release a man with a half-dozen pending cases and active warrants. In Florida, a prosecutor declined to pursue charges against an illegal immigrant who killed a grandmother in a parking lot. The mechanisms differ. The result is the same: the system designed to protect the innocent is working harder to accommodate the accused.
The Post framed Florentino as a "deranged vagrant" and a "career criminal" — and with six pending cases and skipped court dates, the label fits. Fox 4 framed the Florida dismissal as a matter of legal standards, noting prosecutors spent six months searching for a charge that would stick. Both outlets reported the facts. Neither asked the obvious question: how many more Americans have to die before the people running this system admit it is broken?
Judges and prosecutors sworn to uphold public safety are making choices. Ordinary Americans are paying for them.








