A South Carolina convict just freed from federal prison stabbed a man to death at a family gathering thrown to celebrate his release — the latest innocent life lost to a system that keeps betting public safety on the rehabilitation of career criminals.
Fifty-year-old Cedrick Cunningham was arrested Monday and charged with murder and possession of a weapon during a violent crime after killing 42-year-old Andre Smith, according to WIS News 10. Smith suffered a laceration to his chest, managed to get into his vehicle, and was found dead at the scene, the Richland County Coroner's Office confirmed.
Cunningham had been released from federal prison after serving time on a 2019 weapons conviction. His record was serious enough to qualify him for enhanced sentencing under the federal Armed Career Criminal Act — a statute designed specifically for repeat offenders who refuse to stop carrying illegal guns. He was sentenced to 10 years after authorities found him in possession of cocaine, crack cocaine, marijuana, and a pistol with ammunition.
In 2023, Cunningham asked a judge for compassionate release, writing that he had grown from his time away and was an "active" father of three college graduates. "I'm just humbly and respectfully requesting a second chance to prove to my children that I can be a 'law abiding' citizen," he wrote, according to the Daily Mail. The judge denied that request. He got out anyway.
The Post Millennial reported the facts straight: career criminal, enhanced sentencing statute, denied compassionate release, released anyway, killed a man at his own welcome-home party. The Detroit Free Press, meanwhile, spent its ink on a different kind of criminal justice story — a Michigan woman, Tashiena Combs, who served nearly 27 years of a life sentence before a judge vacated her first-degree murder conviction because her trial attorney had an undisclosed sexual relationship with her sister and was simultaneously representing that sister in a case arising from the same shooting. The Oakland County Prosecutor's Conviction Integrity Unit agreed Combs was entitled to relief.
Both stories expose a broken system — just from opposite ends. Combs sat in a cell for nearly three decades while her lawyer's conflict of interest buried evidence that could have supported a self-defense claim. Cunningham walked free despite a rap sheet that triggered a federal statute meant to keep violent repeat offenders locked up. One woman was oversentenced after a constitutionally tainted trial; one man was undersupervised after a career of gun and drug crimes. Andre Smith is dead because the system chose wrong.
Cunningham is now being held at the Alvin S. Glenn Detention Center. The question no one in the reform movement will answer is simple: how many Andre Smiths are acceptable collateral damage for second chances?








