Gov. Gavin Newsom is moving to commute every death sentence in California — 548 of them — to life without parole before he leaves office on Jan. 3, single-handedly nullifying the judgments of juries and the expressed will of voters who twice upheld capital punishment at the ballot box.
One man is wiping away half a thousand death sentences not on the merits of any individual case, but because he personally disagrees with the law. That's not criminal justice reform. That's one executive telling the public their votes don't count.
More than half of California's county prosecutors have joined the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation in petitioning the state Supreme Court to halt the mass commutation. Their filing pulls no punches: "Only this Court can stop the Governor's disregard of the law — his abuse of power."
The prosecutors argue Newsom blew past required procedural steps, failing to provide formal notice to district attorneys and declining to review each case individually. "By the Governor's own account, his decision was not based upon an individualized assessment of the circumstances of the crimes, the histories of the offenders, their conduct during incarceration, or the views of the victims and prosecuting district attorneys," the petition states. "Instead, the Governor made a categorical determination that every death sentence should be commuted based upon his general opposition to capital punishment."
Victims' families called it "a slap in the face." California voters affirmed the death penalty in referenda twice — yet one governor with national ambitions is overriding them en masse.
But legal experts say the prosecutors' challenge is dead on arrival. Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of UC Berkeley Law, called the arguments "frivolous" at a news conference hosted by Prosecutors Alliance Action. "If we just focus on the law, it's clear that Gov. Newsom has the authority to commute these sentences in this way."
Berkeley law professor Elisabeth Semel, who runs the school's Death Penalty Clinic, was harsher: "Either the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and the district attorneys do not understand what the governor did on Nov. 5 ... or do not understand the law."
Here's the procedural reality: Under California law, at least four state supreme court justices must approve commutations for condemned inmates with additional felony convictions — the majority of those on death row. Newsom formally sought that approval when he announced his intent on Nov. 5. Chemerinsky says the constitution and penal code require no individualized determination — meaning the governor can commute by category, not just by case.
So the legal question appears settled in Newsom's favor. The political question is not. The prosecutors' petition may fail, but it documents something real: a governor treating 548 distinct criminal proceedings — each with its own jury, its own victims, its own record — as a single line item he can cross out on his way out the door.
The courts may say he can. The voters already said he shouldn't. The tension between what is legal and what is legitimate is where this story lives.








