Charlotte, North Carolina, wants a judge to throw out the wrongful death lawsuit filed after a Ukrainian refugee was stabbed to death on a city light rail train — because the government says it isn't responsible when its systems fail the people they're supposed to protect.
Iryna Zarutska, 23, survived a bomb shelter in Ukraine only to be slaughtered on an American commuter train. Now the city she trusted for safety wants legal immunity from her family's demand for accountability.
Zarutska was fatally stabbed from behind on August 22, 2025, while riding a Charlotte blue line train home from her shift at a pizzeria. Her attacker, Decarlos Brown Jr., was a homeless man with a diagnosed schizophrenia history who, according to the Charlotte Observer, had previously told police about his condition. Brown was charged with first-degree murder and later deemed incompetent to stand trial; he now sits in a federal medical facility while the state tries to restore his competency. Brown wrote to the criminal court claiming someone was "controlling" his body and that law enforcement "refuses to investigate it."
The lawsuit, filed by Zarutska's uncle Frank Scott Haskell — who was hosting Zarutska and her family in Charlotte — names the city and its contracted security firm, Professional Security Services. Haskell alleged the city and its security knew about crime problems on public transit and "were responsible for protecting lawful passengers from known and foreseeable dangers. Their failures caused the fatal stabbing," according to The Guardian.
Charlotte's response: dismiss the case "with prejudice" — meaning permanently, no refiling. The city's lawyers wrote that Charlotte "recognizes the tragic and devastating death" but "denies that it ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack." The city claims it maintained "an extensive security program" with armed and unarmed security and police services. The motion came after mediation talks failed earlier this month.
HotAir reported that Brown was captured on surveillance video saying "I got that white girl" as he wandered through the carriages dripping blood — a detail establishment outlets largely buried. The New York Times, according to social media accounts cited by HotAir, never published a single story on the murder. Draw your own conclusions about what the press decides is and isn't newsworthy.
The Guardian framed the story as a legal dispute over municipal liability. HotAir framed it as a catastrophic failure of criminal justice and mental health policy, with media complicity in suppressing the racial dimension of the attack. What neither outlet disputes: a severely mentally ill man with a known diagnosis was free to roam the streets and ride public transit until he killed someone. And the government's answer to the family is: sue us, but you can't.
Zarutska came to the United States after living in a bomb shelter. She believed this country was safer than a war zone. The question no official wants to answer: why should Americans — or anyone we take in — trust a system that releases dangerous people onto trains and then claims immunity when the inevitable happens?








