New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed a law Thursday abolishing the horse-drawn carriage industry by 2028, and the union representing roughly 200 drivers filed a federal lawsuit within minutes — because the politicians applauding themselves on City Hall's Blue Room stage wrote nothing into the law guaranteeing the workers a dime.
The legislation, dubbed Romanch's Law after an 18-year-old Indian tourist killed when a horse spooked in Central Park this June, ends an industry that has operated in the city for over a century. Mamdani called it a new chapter. For the drivers, medallion owners, and stable hands who showed up to work this morning, it's doomsday.
The Guardian framed the signing as a historic animal-welfare milestone, quoting Mamdani and Council Speaker Julie Menin emphasizing the city's "responsibility" to displaced workers and promising transition support. The New York Post led with what the Guardian buried: the union's immediate lawsuit and the fact that the law itself contains no mandated compensation.
TWU International President John Samuelsen didn't mince words. "This bill is an unconstitutional abomination," he said. "It strips horse-carriage owners of the city-issued medallions that they purchased for hundreds of thousands of dollars – without mandating or guaranteeing compensation."
The administration says it will offer medallion buy-backs, stipends, career counseling, and tuition assistance. A full transition plan won't be released until April 2027. The union's point is simple: if the city meant any of that, it should have written it into the statute. Instead, the promises are just promises — and the workers are supposed to trust the same politicians who just outlawed their livelihoods.
The union also highlighted a glaring double standard. Between 2019 and May 2026, e-bikes injured 17,434 people and killed 113 in New York City. The Mamdani administration has done next to nothing to regulate that industry. But one tragic carriage incident? Ban the whole trade.
TWU Local 100 Executive Vice President Alexander Kemp put it plainly: "I never imagined a world where people who champion labor would take such pride in eliminating it from Central Park."
Bill de Blasio, who pushed for this ban for years and never got it done, stood beaming behind Mamdani at the signing. The optics told the whole story: politicians clapping, workers suing.
The city says it will study electric carriages and pedal-assist bikes as replacements. So the same e-bikes the union says are killing New Yorkers might become the official substitute for the horses the city says it's protecting. The feasibility study will presumably not cover the feasibility of politicians keeping their word.
The open question is whether a federal court will agree that destroying the contractual and property rights of 200 working New Yorkers — without guaranteed compensation written into law — passes constitutional muster. The union is betting it doesn't.








