Three people are dead and at least two wounded after a gunman opened fire inside an In-N-Out Burger in Twin Falls, Idaho, Saturday afternoon — and the legacy press can't even agree on whether the shooter is alive or dead.

In the rush to report, outlets have already contradicted each other on the most basic facts of the case. CNN reported definitively that "the shooter is deceased," citing city spokesperson Josh Palmer. CBS News, meanwhile, led with the claim that "the suspect remained at large" — though it later noted Palmer said the gunman was "no longer considered a threat." NBC News hedged, reporting that Palmer "could not confirm whether the shooter was among the people killed." The Associated Press, relying on county commissioner and former Idaho prison chief Brent Reinke, reported the shooter "is also down." These are not minor discrepancies. They are the foundation of the entire story.

What is actually confirmed: Police responded to what they called an "active shooter incident" at or near the In-N-Out on Blue Lakes Boulevard North before 2:30 p.m. local time. Three victims are dead and at least two injured, according to Palmer. The shooting began inside the restaurant. Multiple agencies responded, roads and the nearby Perrine Bridge were shut down, and surrounding businesses — including a Chick-fil-A and the Magic Valley Mall — locked down or closed. A mall employee told NBC News: "We are currently in a lockdown. There has been a mass shooting."

St. Luke's Magic Valley medical center said it was "working closely with law enforcement and emergency responders," according to spokesperson Taylor Marschner. Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador posted on X that state police and first responders were working to secure the area.

What is not confirmed: the identity of the shooter, any motive, the exact sequence of events, and — critically — the shooter's current status. Social media video obtained by CBS News shows people fleeing a parking lot as gunshots ring out and a person carrying what appears to be a firearm opening the door of a parked sedan. That detail, if verified, raises obvious questions about whether there was a vehicle waiting, whether multiple people were involved, and whether the suspect fled the scene. Palmer would not say if there was only one suspect, according to CBS News.

CNN couldn't resist editorializing, inserting a line about how the shooting "added to a growing list of shootings this summer that have sent people fleeing from ordinary places" — framing the incident as part of a national trend before a single fact about motive or method has been established. That's narrative construction, not reporting.

Twin Falls is a city of roughly 56,000, a regional hub about 130 miles southeast of Boise. Idaho Sens. Mike Crapo and Rep. Mike Simpson offered statements urging residents to follow law enforcement directions and expressing gratitude for first responders.

The public needs facts: who did this, why, and how it ended. Until investigators release those details, every broader claim is speculation dressed up as news.