A federal jury finally convicted the man who started the deadly Palisades Fire on Friday — but it took two full trials, a narrowed indictment, and a judge blocking the defense's key witness to get there, while 12 dead Americans waited nearly two years for accountability.
Jonathan Rinderknecht, 30, was found guilty of destruction of property by fire and arson affecting interstate commerce for igniting the January 2025 blaze that killed a dozen people and destroyed more than 6,800 structures in Pacific Palisades and Malibu. Sentencing is set for March 17, 2027.
The verdict comes after his first trial ended in a mistrial when jurors deadlocked 10-2 in favor of acquittal. The overwhelming majority of the first panel wanted to let him walk free. Prosecutors had to drop a timber-burning charge and narrow the remaining allegations before taking a second swing.
The government's case was straightforward: Rinderknecht, a former Uber driver, used a barbecue-style lighter to ignite a brush fire on a hillside in the early hours of New Year's Day 2025. Firefighters suppressed what became known as the Lachman Fire, but embers smoldered underground for a week before Santa Ana winds whipping up to 100 mph whipped them back to life on January 7, spawning the catastrophic Palisades Fire.
Cellphone tower data placed Rinderknecht alone near the ignition point. DNA on the lighter recovered from his vehicle matched his own, according to prosecutors. After the fire started, Rinderknecht called 911 more than a dozen times — and screen-recorded himself doing it, which prosecutors argued was a manufactured alibi. He also asked ChatGPT mid-crisis: "Are you at fault if a fire is lit because of your cigarettes?"
At the first trial, prosecutors leaned hard into a "societal revenge" theory, painting Rinderknecht as a man enraged by wealth inequality and personal failures. That pitch flopped. CNN reported that for the retrial, prosecutors pivoted to a tighter case built on digital forensics and physical evidence rather than motive rhetoric. The strategy worked.
One retrial juror, identified only as Cameron, told reporters he was initially the lone holdout for acquittal before changing his mind. "Everything kind of started to point to one conclusion — especially if there was no one else on that hill," he said, citing Rinderknecht's own statements that he was on the hill that night, smelled no fire, and saw no fireworks.
The defense argued fireworks caused the blaze and tried to introduce testimony from fire investigator Michael T. Cole about suspected fireworks residue on the driveway of former NBA star Chris Bosh's nearby mansion. The judge refused to admit it. The Guardian noted that prosecutors dismissed the fireworks theory as "baseless" in a court filing, and CNN reported that experts at the retrial eliminated every other ignition source, including fireworks.
Critically, jurors in the retrial were explicitly instructed not to consider the Los Angeles Fire Department's role in failing to fully extinguish the Lachman Fire before it reignited. The Guardian reported that first-trial jurors had been wary of pinning blame solely on Rinderknecht precisely because of LAFD's failure — and that concern is now officially off the table.
Fire victim Jeremy Padawer told the New York Post the guilty verdict matters but added: "That verdict does not absolve the city, the state, or the leaders responsible for their extraordinary gross negligence." Outgoing Mayor Karen Bass, who was in Ghana when the blaze erupted, offered a statement acknowledging that "no verdict can bring back the lives lost."
Rinderknecht's father, Joel, maintained his son's innocence after the verdict: "It feels like when you're in front of the government, it's a big machine, like a steamroller. There's not much you can do."
Twelve Americans are dead. Thousands of homes are ash. A man who apparently Googled his own culpability in real time nearly walked free the first time around. The system got there eventually — but the first jury's near-acquittal and the judge's decision to shield LAFD's failures from scrutiny raise a question that won't go away: who else isn't being held to account?







