Susan Smith, who strapped her two toddler sons into their car seats and rolled them into a South Carolina lake to drown in 1994, was unanimously denied parole Thursday — and the only story here is that a parole board doing its job somehow qualifies as breaking news.
Smith, 55, needed two-thirds support from the seven-member board to walk free. She didn't get it. Under South Carolina law at the time of her conviction, she became eligible after 30 years and can reapply every two years. She was also denied unanimously in 2024. She can ask again in 2028.
The board grants parole in only 4% of cases, and the majority of those are non-violent offenders, according to the South Carolina Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services. Smith is serving life for the deliberate murder of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex. The math should never have been close.
The New York Post led its coverage on the salacious testimony of forensic psychiatrist Dr. Jessie Hill, who told the board about Smith's bizarre childhood "love triangle" with her mother and stepfather. Hill argued Smith had made "significant changes" and blamed her crimes on mental health issues stemming from abuse. The Post also noted that before 2015, Smith was disciplined for drug use and having sex with a prison guard, and in 2024 she was sanctioned for phone conversations with a documentary filmmaker, discussing her crimes in exchange for money deposited into her inmate account.
The Mechanicsburg Patriot News and WYFF, by contrast, focused on David Smith — the boys' father — who pinned the same photograph of his sons over his heart that he wore to the 1995 trial and the 2024 hearing. "She took away one of the greatest gifts God gives us — life. She did that deliberately. It wasn't an accident, it wasn't a mistake. She did it deliberately," he told the board. He told CNN earlier this week he wants to see her "in prison until she dies."
Smith appeared by video and offered an apology without tears — unlike her 2024 hearing. "I know that David didn't get to see Michael and Alex grow up," she said. "I'm not the same person I was 32 years ago."
For nine days in 1994, Smith lied to investigators and the public, claiming a Black man had carjacked her at a stoplight in Union and taken her children. The Patriot News and WYFF both framed this as a "centuries-old racist trope" that "stoked concerns about crime" in 1990s America. What neither outlet lingered on: that false accusation could have sent an innocent man to death row. Investigators' re-creation showed it took six minutes for the Mazda to sink. Her boys were found dangling upside-down in their car seats.
Prosecutors have long argued Smith killed her children because she believed they were the reason a wealthy man broke off their affair. The defense has blamed mental health. The parole board wasn't buying it — either time.
A child murderer stays behind bars. That's not a headline. It's the bare minimum. The question is what happens in 2028, and whether the system keeps remembering Michael and Alex when the cameras aren't there.








