Stephen A. Smith told the press corps this week that he won't play fact-check referee during a presidential interview — and legacy media can't stand that viewers might hear a president unfiltered.
Smith sat down with President Trump in the Roosevelt Room last week, and instead of interrupting every sentence to perform pushback for the cameras, he let Trump talk. That drove media insiders nuts. Smith's response: the point of an interview is getting the subject on the record, not grandstanding.
"You don't walk into the White House and talk to the president of the United States and plan on fact-checking him on the spot or interrupting him every sentence that he utters out of his mouth," Smith said Tuesday on his "Straight Shooter" podcast. "You know why? Because you won't get through the damn interview. That's why."
Smith said critics — described as "people who have been in this industry before" — accused him of going soft. HuffPost framed Smith's stance as "eyebrow-raising," as though the obvious play was to pick a fight and tank the sit-down. Smith acknowledged Trump "doesn't hesitate to embellish" and tends to filibuster, but said the calculus is simple: keep him in the chair, or get nothing.
"I wanted to be able to challenge and push back in certain respects, but in the same breath, keep him in the damn chair because he does have the potential to just get up and walk off as he has done to people before," Smith said. HuffPost noted that Trump walked out on "Meet the Press" host Kristen Walker in June after she pressed him on multiple issues — proving Smith's point.
Smith's method: capture the claims, then verify. "The goal, at least for me, is not to fact-check them on the spot in most instances," he said. "It's to make sure that they're quoted for the record, so we always have them on the record about what their positions are. That way, when we go back to double- and triple-check the facts, we're able to say, 'Hey, that wasn't true.'" Smith then spent the rest of his video doing exactly that — fact-checking Trump's statements after the interview.
Newsbusters Managing Editor Curtis Houck backed Smith's approach, telling Fox News Digital: "A constant state of antagonistic fact-checks or baboonish hectoring can derail an interview and prevent it from creating headlines other than its combative nature. As much as liberal, elitist journalists claim otherwise, so many love being the headline."
NPR's own reporting this week demonstrates why after-the-fact verification works: the White House claimed credit for a historic plunge in drug overdose deaths, attributing gains to Trump's policies over 18 months. NPR found the declines began in 2023 under Biden, with most improvement occurring before Trump returned to office. Real-time cross-examination wouldn't have produced that context — follow-up reporting did.
Smith put it plainly: "Ladies and gentlemen, this is chess, it ain't checkers. And if every politician had to get fact-checked in real time, you wouldn't get interviews." The press corps wants checkers. The question is whether they want the public informed, or just managed.








