Los Angeles Unified School District handed $6.35 million of taxpayer money to phone-lock companies — and more than half its high schoolers say the ban has done little or nothing to help them focus in class. Another government program, another bill for working Americans, another round of excuses from the bureaucrats who ran it.
The district spent $5.42 million on Yondr, the magnetically locked phone pouches, and nearly $930,000 more at Amazon for other locking devices during the 2024-25 school year, according to records first obtained by LAist. The board sold the ban as a fix for mental health, bullying, and classroom distractions. The numbers tell a different story.
Of 93,000 students surveyed in the district's spring 2026 School Experience Survey, 27.3% said the phone ban didn't improve their focus at all, and 28.5% reported only slight improvement. Just 15.6% said they focused better all the time. Nearly half of staff — 47.3% — said the policy reduced behavior problems only "somewhat" or "not at all." And 15.8% of staff said students simply didn't follow the ban.
Students have already figured out how to beat the pouches, slipping dummy phones inside or breaking them outright. As USC education professor Morgan Polikoff put it: "Students are crafty and can defeat many policies."
The district's response? Spin. An LAUSD spokesperson told the California Post the results show "encouraging progress" and that the district knew "changing habits would take time." The spokesperson cherry-picked the brighter numbers — nearly six in 10 students reported more in-person social interaction, about half reported better focus — while the district quietly admitted its own survey "does not, by itself, establish a causal relationship between the policy and changes in student outcomes." In plain English: they can't prove it works.
The New York Post framed the story around student and staff dissatisfaction with the ban's results. Breitbart took a wider lens, citing a Harvard study of 3.3 million students across 4,600 schools that found strict phone restrictions produce "modest" academic gains — roughly one to two extra weeks of learning per year. Harvard professor Thomas Kane called it "not a panacea." A separate National Bureau of Economic Research study found "close to zero" effect on test scores overall, with only modest gains in high school math. Both studies essentially agree: phone bans help a little, but they don't fix what's broken.
Follow the money. Yondr walks away with over $5 million from one district alone. More than 40 states have now passed some form of phone restriction in schools, according to the Phone Free Schools State Report Card — which means the pouch lobby has a massive and growing customer base funded by your tax dollars. Meanwhile, parents had no real say in LAUSD's decision. The board voted, the contract went out, and families got the bill.
The board extended the ban to cover the full school day — lunch and passing periods included — starting in February 2025. The district is now pushing a "Heads Up, Phones Down" campaign with student-made content and phone-free lunch activities. They'll keep "refining our approach," the spokesperson said. Translation: they'll keep spending.
Government schools can't teach, can't enforce their own rules, and can't stop burning cash on solutions that don't solve anything. The question isn't whether phones distract kids — they do. The question is why, once again, the people who pay the tab had no seat at the table, and the people who got paid are the ones selling the locks.








