The New York City Council is debating how lobsters die while New Yorkers are being stabbed in subway stations and restaurants are buckling under taxes, rent, and crime.
Councilmembers Oswald Feliz of the Bronx and Harvey Epstein of Manhattan introduced legislation this week that would prohibit food service establishments from placing live crustaceans — lobsters, crabs, and anything else with a shell — into boiling liquid for cooking. A first violation carries no fine. A second or subsequent violation would cost up to $100.
The bill does not ban lobster from menus. Restaurants could still serve it, provided the animal is killed first. The proposal mirrors laws already on the books in New Zealand, Austria, and Norway.
Feliz, who chairs the Council's Committee on Public Safety, told the New York Post that "boiling an animal alive is the textbook definition of animal cruelty."
"Some argue that lobsters don't feel pain. If they don't feel pain, why do they thrash around and desperately try to escape when thrown into boiling water?" he said.
The science is contested. The Post Millennial reported that animal activists claim crustaceans feel pain like mammals do, while others note their nervous systems do not process pain the same way. The New York Post, in an opinion piece, was more blunt — calling them "primitive creatures" with "no brains" who "can't complain on TikTok or mount a street protest."
What is not contested is who pays. Restaurant owners — already squeezed by high rents, food costs, labor costs, and taxes — see the bill as one more burden from a council that has lost touch with working New Yorkers.
Retired Italian restaurateur Angelo Vivolo called it "idiocy."
"What's next, do they want to introduce not using cow for meat or forget about prosciutto at an Italian restaurant? Forget about it!" he said. "This regulation is absolutely insane."
Another chef told The Post Millennial he would scrap plans for a new restaurant over the proposal. "Restaurants are fighting high rents, food costs, labor costs and taxes. Now we're supposed to worry about hurting a lobster's feelings? What's next? Are we going to need permission from City Hall before we crack a crab leg?"
The New York Post framed the bill as a question of moral priorities, and the facts back that framing up. Feliz chairs the Public Safety Committee while representing the 15th District in the central Bronx — neighborhoods with some of the city's highest violent-crime rates, including homicide. Epstein, representing Greenwich Village and downtown Manhattan, was a prime mover behind the recently signed ban on carriage horses, a century-old Central Park institution that put working coachmen out of a livelihood.
The Post also reported that the council has floated giving workers sick days to care for ailing pets, banning citizens from keeping elephants, and requiring government agencies to buy only free-range eggs.
The Post Millennial reported the bill more straightforwardly — the text, the sponsors, the penalties, the restaurant pushback — without pressing on the broader question of council priorities. The New Post opinion piece supplied the edge: that this is a government putting crustacean comfort over human survival.
The bill has not passed. It has been proposed. But the fact that a council member charged with public safety in a district where people are dying looked at New York City and decided the urgent problem is how lobsters meet their end tells you where the left's moral hierarchy sits.
The council has not yet scheduled a hearing. Whether it advances — and whether New Yorkers tolerate a government that ranks crab legs below crime — is the real test.







