California Governor Gavin Newsom is being sued by prosecutors and families of murder victims after he unilaterally moved to commute the death sentences of more than 500 condemned killers, overriding jury verdicts and denying victims their legal right to be heard.
The petition, filed Monday with the California Supreme Court by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation on behalf of 30 county district attorneys and over two dozen family members of murder victims, argues Newsom abused his power by issuing a blanket commutation without the individualized review the law requires — and without notifying the families of those heinous crimes before making his announcement.
"Thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges set aside their personal views on the merits of the death penalty to render judgments based on the evidence and the law," the filing states. "Governor Newsom decided his personal views should override all those who actually participated in the process, followed and applied the law."
Marc Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter Polly was abducted and murdered in 1993, told CNN the move proved that "the criminal justice system can turn on a whim."
Newsom announced on November 5 that he intends to commute the sentences of all 548 people on California's death row — 529 men and 19 women. In an open letter, he declared that "state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with" California's values and called the system for administering the death penalty "a failure." He acknowledged the move was "among the most difficult of my career."
But difficulty is not the constitutional test. Under the California Constitution, the state Supreme Court must affirm any commutation for a felon with more than one felony conviction — a condition met by roughly 70 percent of the condemned inmates, meaning the court would need to sign off on approximately 382 of Newsom's proposed commutations. The plaintiffs say Newsom circumvented the required notice to victims, denying them the opportunity to be heard before a decision was made.
Whether a governor can issue a blanket commutation of this scale is uncharted legal territory. University of Pacific law professor Michael Vitiello told NBC News there is no record of a previous mass commutation and no established precedent to guide the court.
NBC News noted that while the plaintiffs have the general backing of California law enforcement, a handful of district attorneys broke ranks to support Newsom. Santa Clara County DA Jeff Rosen, in a statement released by the advocacy group Smart Justice California, said the state would be safer by abandoning "outdated and ineffective practices like the death penalty." CNN, for its part, highlighted support from the ACLU and Paul Wilson, a murder victim's husband who reversed his own position on capital punishment.
Neither outlet pressed the constitutional question at the heart of this fight: whether one executive's moral conviction can lawfully erase the considered judgments of hundreds of juries across decades — without even the courtesy of notice to the families left behind.
California has not carried out an execution since 2006. Newsom imposed a formal moratorium on the death penalty in 2019. The question now is whether a governor can simply declare the debate over and empty death row by fiat — or whether the courts will force him to follow the process the state constitution demands.








