A Charleston County investigator admitted to conflicting details in a murder defendant's account of a 2020 shooting — and defense attorneys spent cross-examination exposing whether the investigator even understood what the defendant was telling him, raising questions about whether the state can prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.
When investigators bungle evidence or mishear a suspect, the system doesn't just fail the accused — it fails the victim and every citizen counting on the courts to get it right.
Anthony Simmons-Dunmeyer is charged with murder in the Sept. 2, 2020 shooting death of Manuel Foy Jr. in McClellanville. According to Live 5 News WCSC, the lead investigator walked jurors through Simmons-Dunmeyer's interview, in which he denied shooting Foy and blamed an unidentified third person who allegedly demanded something before opening fire.
Simmons-Dunmeyer claimed he ran toward a red vehicle near where Foy was shot, despite the alleged gunman still being in the area. He said the third person pointed a gun at him, he heard it click, and the person fled. He then described dragging Foy's body around the car, asking who shot him.
But Simmons-Dunmeyer never called 911. The investigator testified he offered shifting explanations: his phone was dead, his girlfriend didn't want blood on her car seats, he offered a homeowner $15 to drive Foy to the hospital but she had no vehicle, and he was told not to track blood into the house. He then went to a relative's home, took a Lyft to a family storage facility to "meditate," and was found during a traffic stop three weeks later. He also claimed family members prevented him from contacting law enforcement.
That's the defendant's story, and it's full of holes. But the defense made clear the state's case has holes of its own.
During cross-examination, defense attorneys challenged whether the investigator accurately understood Simmons-Dunmeyer's language, accent, and expressions during the interview. They pressed on a key discrepancy: whether Simmons-Dunmeyer initially described running toward a white vehicle before the red one. If the investigator misheard or misrecorded basic facts about the defendant's own movements, what else did he get wrong?
The WCSC report cuts off before detailing the full scope of the defense's challenge to evidence handling, leaving an open question about what else the state may have failed to document properly.
In a separate case out of Spring Lake, North Carolina, KABC-TV reported that Shaville Burnett-Grant faces first-degree murder charges in the shooting death of her husband, rapper Darrin Burnett. She claims she fired a warning shot into the ground during an argument over his alleged drug use, and that the gun discharged when he tried to grab it. Prosecutors called her behavior after the shooting "bizarre," noting Clorox was found near the scene and a gun was hidden 20 feet away. Even the victim's mother, Kendra Phelps, urged restraint: "I'm not here to put the blame. I understand it was a lot going on."
Two cases, two dead men, two defendants with contested stories — and in both, the difference between conviction and acquittal may come down to whether investigators did their jobs carefully enough to prove what actually happened. Due process isn't a technicality. It's the only thing standing between a verdict and a guess.






