A Florida man who called himself "AlphaSadist" online is standing trial for the kidnapping and murder of a mentally ill British woman he groomed for two years on a fetish website — and unlike catch-and-release jurisdictions where progressive DAs cut killers loose, this state is putting him before a jury.
Dwain Hall, 54, of Ocala, is charged with first-degree murder and kidnapping in the October 2025 stabbing death of Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old music tutor from Portsmouth, England. Hall has pleaded not guilty. His trial began Tuesday at the Marion County Judicial Center.
The case lays bare a grim internet underworld — and the difference between a justice system that prosecutes violent crime and one that doesn't.
Prosecutor Amy Beth Berndt told jurors that Hall tried to "erase every trace of Sonia from his phone" as investigators closed in, but a forensic examiner recovered nude photos, video, and what Berndt described as "numerous images of women being raped, tortured and murdered" — including photographs of women with knives shoved into their bodies and nails piercing their breasts. The New York Post reported Berndt's opening statement in graphic detail; Us Weekly did not report this evidence at all, focusing instead on Exelby's mental health struggles and her family's grief.
Both outlets agree on the core timeline. Exelby flew from London to Gainesville on October 10, 2025. Hall picked her up at the airport and drove her to an Airbnb in Reddick, Florida. UK authorities declared her endangered after she missed her return flight on October 13. Her remains were found in a shallow grave in Marion Oaks on October 17.
The premeditation evidence is damning. Hall purchased a shovel, two kinds of rope, and gun oil at Walmart before picking Exelby up, according to a receipt found at the Airbnb — a detail reported by the Post but absent from Us Weekly's coverage.
Exelby had been communicating with Hall on a site called Motherless, which Berndt said allowed users to upload images of women being raped, tortured, and murdered, as well as child pornography. The site has since been shut down, its servers seized, and a criminal investigation is ongoing. Hall's profile, under the username "AlphaSadist," read: "Would love to find a domestic pain slut for complete control."
Exelby was suicidal and had been seeking someone to kill her, according to the arrest affidavit. But messages she sent a friend via Discord in her final days reveal a woman who wanted out. "I'm sorry he keeps taking my phone he doesn't trust me with it," she wrote. "He made it clear there was no way out unless I shoot him. I was questioning it last night. I can't kill anyone." She added: "I'm so so scared I'm so broken and in so much pain."
A video Hall recorded of Exelby at the Airbnb on October 11 showed bruises and abrasions on her body, per the affidavit. The next morning, the Airbnb owner received a checkout notification — days before her body was discovered.
Hall's attorney, Junior Barrett, offered a brief opening statement, telling jurors they would need to "listen to all the witnesses and determine what actually happened."
Exelby's sister, Gemma Isaj, described her as "a beautiful, gentle and incredibly kind soul" who "struggled with her mental health" but was "so much more than the difficulties she faced."
The affidavit states Hall "knew Exelby suffered from severe mental illness and was suicidal" and claimed he wanted to help her, but that "his actions show differently."
Here's the contrast that matters: Florida is trying this man for first-degree murder and kidnapping, full stop. No plea deal quietly reducing the charges. No progressive DA citing the defendant's background as mitigating. A vulnerable woman was preyed upon and killed, and the state is seeking accountability. Whether the jury delivers it remains to be seen.






