A foreign national who plotted to assassinate a U.S. citizen on American soil at the behest of a foreign government was sentenced Friday to more than 19 years in federal prison — a case that lays bare how freely foreign intelligence operates inside this country.
Nikhil Gupta, 55, admitted to orchestrating an Indian government-backed plot to kill Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a dual U.S.-Canadian citizen and lawyer for Sikhs for Justice in New York who advocates for a sovereign Sikh state in northern India. Judge Victor Marrero handed down the 235-month sentence in Manhattan federal court. Gupta pleaded guilty in February to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
The plot reads like a spy novel. Gupta arranged to pay $15,000 in cash to a man he believed was a hitman. That man was an undercover U.S. law enforcement officer. Gupta was arrested in Prague and has been held without bail since his extradition to the U.S. in June 2023.
But here's what should alarm every American: Gupta was working with an Indian government official, Vikash Yadav, who is also charged in the case — and who is not in U.S. custody. It is unclear whether Yadav has even hired a defense lawyer. The man who directed this operation from inside a foreign government walks free.
India has denied involvement, calling the plot against government policy. Pannun wasn't buying it. In court, he described Gupta as "just a foot soldier acting at the behest" of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, saying Modi's administration wants him dead "because I lead the campaign openly, defy threats and intimidation."
The Guardian framed the story primarily through the lens of diplomatic friction, noting the case has "tested relations with India." WTOP, carrying AP reporting, provided fuller courtroom detail — including Gupta's lawyer, Isabelle Kirshner, arguing he was "not the brains behind this operation" and urging Marrero not to sentence him "as a rebuke to India."
The deeper story runs through Canada. According to court papers, Gupta told the undercover officer that Hardeep Singh Nijjar — a Sikh separatist killed outside a temple in British Columbia in June 2023 — "was also the target" and that "we have so many targets." Gupta instructed the officer to proceed with Pannun's killing now that Nijjar was dead. Kirshner dismissed talk of assassination plots in Nepal and Pakistan as "pure puffery."
The threats haven't stopped. In August, Pannun said the FBI and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police warned him of a new credible threat to his life.
Prosecutor Ashley Nicolas told the court the case "cuts to the very core of American values," adding: "We don't condone the use of violence to silence voices in this country, ever."
That's a fine sentiment. But the reality is that a foreign government plotted a political assassination on U.S. soil, the foot soldier got 19 years, and the official who ran the operation from inside that government faces no consequences anyone can see. Gupta faces deportation after his sentence. The intelligence apparatus that greenlit this operation is intact.
The question isn't whether Gupta deserved prison. He did. The question is what happens when a foreign government decides it can kill Americans on American soil — and the only person who pays is the man they hired to make the call.








